Why Your Website Traffic Isn’t Converting (And How One Landing Page Can Fix It)
Alright small business owner, here you are running your biz, making the widgets, doing the back office admin and marketing (yes, even low-cost marketing for your small business!) You’re literally doing ALL the things.
You’re posting on social platforms (assuming you’ve chosen the right social media channels for your business!) You’re emailing your audience (using drip and nurture campaigns) because you know the power of consistency.Maybe you even sent out a mailer (because yes, print marketing still works!) or paid a few dollars a day for Meta ads.
People are clicking! Google Analytics says you’re getting more traffic to your site.
But.Despite ALLLLL that.It’s still crickets in your payment platform.
Customers are looking in your digital windows, but they’re not actually checking out at the register.
No purchases.No booked calls.No email opt-ins.
At some point, you start asking yourself:“Is my offer bad?”“Is my pricing wrong?”“Do I need to redo my whole website?”
“Should I just quit this business thing altogether?”
Here’s the good news: most of the time, this lack of conversions has nothing to do with your talent, your credibility, or even your offer. (Although, if you create the right offer, it can be so compelling that it’s hard to say no!)
It’s almost always a clarity issue, and the bottom line is: confused people don’t buy.
The hard truth no one tells you about websites
Websites are decision-making machines. And most small business websites ask people to make way too many decisions at once.
Think about what happens when someone lands on your site:
Multiple menu options
Several services
A few different CTAs
An about page you worked really hard on
Maybe a pop-up for good measure
Now imagine that person has:
Two minutes (but usually less!)
A short attention span
Zero emotional investment yet
When people don’t know what to do next, they don’t do anything.
They leave.Bounce. Bounce. 👋
🥁Drumroll please.
This is where a landing page comes in, stage left. This is when landing pages can quietly do their best work.
What a landing page actually is (and what it’s not)
A landing page is not a prettier version of your whole website.
It’s not a mini website.It’s not your homepage.It’s not a biography.It’s definitely not a scrolling memoir about your entrepreneurial journey (no matter how lovely it might be) or how you overcame imposter syndrome and other small business owner mindset blocks.
A landing page has one job and one job only: Get someone to take one specific action.
Your website is like walking into a party and shouting:
“Hi everyone! I do a lot of things! Come find me if you want!”
LOL, k, sounds good, bye.
But your landing page is when you tap one person on the shoulder and say:
“Hey, you. I know exactly why you’re here, and I have something for you.”
Same room. Same business.Completely different result.
When a landing page is the right move
Landing pages are ideal when you’re:
Running ads that are targeting a specific type of person (hey you vs hey everyone) and ideally you’ve already mapped out your small business user personas for this step!
Promoting a single service or product
Offering a free download or lead magnet (that converts!)
Booking calls or consultations
Sending people from email or social to one thing
If you’re driving traffic to a homepage and hoping people “figure it out,” you’re making it harder than it needs to be.
The most common landing page mistakes we see
As your marketing besties, you know we’re gonna call it as we see it. And these are the biggest landing page mistakes we see, even from the hands of smart, capable business owners.
Too many calls to action (CTAs)
You want them to:
Learn more
Read the blog
Follow you
Book a call
Download something
Check out your services
What happens if you list ALL of these CTAs? Your prospect does nothing. They bounce.
It’s like when you’re at a diner (literally any diner, you know what I mean), and you start looking at the menu, and by the time you’re reading the 50th item, you’re so overwhelmed you don’t know what to order.
Should you have the chicken and waffles? Or the burger? Or the omelette? And then when the waitress comes to take your order, you just default to the grilled cheese and tomato soup because it feels safe? No? Just me?
Your landing page should only have ONE CTA. One thing you want people to do. One option. That’s it.
2. Burying the offer
If someone has to scroll halfway down the page to understand what you’re offering, you’ve already lost them.
Pro Tip: Put the most important information above the fold. That means when someone hits your landing page on their phone or computer, they should be able to see a CTA button and your need-to-know info.
3. Talking about yourself instead of the outcome
Your landing page is not about you. In fact, most of your marketing isn’t either.
That might feel harsh, but it’s true. People care about you later.
Right now, they care about their problem and how your product or service can help them solve it.
Save your story for the About page of your website, or some cute “behind-the-scenes” social post. It has no business on your landing page.
4. Headlines that sound clever but say nothing
If your headline could apply to any business, it’s not doing its job.
Clear over clever. Always!
Read your headline out loud to yourself. Does it sound natural? If your ideal customer were standing right in front of you, would you say it to them? Would they understand it? Would they be ready to buy?
If you said no to any of those, head back to the copywriting board.
OKAY FR, FR: If these tactical, practical marketing tips are helpful, you’ll love the Big Bad Marketing newsletter.
Sign up below to get strategic, useful marketing support delivered straight to your inbox every month, and we’ll toss in a couple of sweet extras for joining our list.
The anatomy of a high-converting landing page (exactly what to include in your landing page!)
You don’t need a fancy design. You need the right page structure. That starts with:
The headline
This is where clarity wins. It’s the ultimate promise you’re making to your audience.
Strong headline formulas:
“Get [specific result] without [specific pain]”
“How to [desired outcome] in [timeframe]”
Lead with the outcome. Always. And if your solution is faster, easier, or simpler than what they’re doing now, say that.
For example, on our landing page, we say “How to organize your marketing in less than 48 hours”. Compelling? Want to know more?
Subheadline
This is where people decide if they’re staying.
Call out:
The exact person
The exact struggle
The exact moment they’re in
When someone thinks, “Oh wow, this is literally me,” you’ve done your job.
The offer (above the fold, please)
Don’t make people hunt.
Be very clear about:
What they get
How it helps
Why it’s valuable
If you can anchor the value so the cost or effort feels reasonable (or even so reasonable they’d be silly not to say yes), even better.
Social proof (even if you think you don’t have any)
Belief is built through proof, not persuasion.
And no, it doesn’t have to be fancy.
Social proof can be:
Testimonials
Screenshots and videos
Emails or DMs
Before-and-after stories
Logos or “as seen in” mentions
Scrappy proof is still proof. That review from your neighbor saying that you did a kick-@$$ job is still proof. We all start somewhere.
How landing pages work (in 3 simple steps)
People want to know:“What happens after I click?”
Show them.
Make it feel easy.
Reduce friction.
When the process feels simple, the decision feels safer.
Outline the exact next steps. If someone will need to fill out a survey or attend an onboarding call, say so on the landing page. Give them MORE information upfront so they have everything they need to make an informed decision. BUT not so much that they get overwhelmed, confused, and bounce! Fine print, contracts, and super-boring, boiler plate details can come later.
The call to action
One page. One action.
Clear button copy beats clever every time.Tell them exactly what you want them to do. And make sure it’s the next step.
That’s right. The tiniest next most thing to do. If you lured someone to the landing page under the guise of getting a free annual marketing calendar, the CTA should be to enter their email address to receive the calendar. If you suddenly ask them to buy a $200 strategic marketing plan, that’s grounds for confusion and a quick exit. Bounce, bounce.
Objection handling
This is where you address the quiet doubts:
“I don’t have time.”
“Is this worth the money?”
“Will this actually work for someone like me?”
This is generally an FAQ section plus a guarantee. If you guarantee results in 30 days or their money back, tell them! Anything you can do to reduce the perceived risk may help encourage them to take action.
Landing page tools you can use (without hiring a developer or being an expert!)
Quick reminder: the tool doesn’t convert. The message converts.
But these tools make execution easier.
Website builders
Landing-page-specific tools
What matters most:
Speed
Mobile-friendliness
Easy edits
Pick a tool you won’t overthink.
How to know if your landing page is working (aka converting)
Once you set your landing page live, there are a few ways to see if it’s doing its job.
Early signs of success:
People are clicking
People are staying on the page
People are taking action (They’re doing the thing you want them to do! Hallelujah!)
Metrics to watch:
Conversion rate
Cost per lead (if you’re running ads)
Over time, you’d expect the conversion rate to increase (a higher percentage of visitors are taking action) and your cost per lead to go down (the leads hitting your page are more likely to convert and bring in $$)
When something isn’t working, tweak in this order:
Headline (Since this is the first thing someone sees, make this change first before you do anything else)
Call to action
Offer
A/B test very small changes. Change only one word or one sentence, then set it live. If you change the headline and the CTA on the same day, you don’t actually know which one was responsible for increasing or tanking your conversions.
One change at a time. Give it time to have impact and collect data. Then review. Get clearer. Fix the actual problem.
Because once people know exactly what to do, they’re a whole lot more likely to do it! So give them the map, and make it easy to read!
Build a small business landing page that converts
If your traffic isn’t converting, it doesn’t mean your business is broken, it means you might need to work on your landing page.
You don’t need to start over, scrap your website, or question your entire offer. You just need to make it easier for the right person to understand what you do and take the next step.
What to do next
If you’re ready to create a small business landing page that converts, here’s exactly what to do:
Update your landing page with a single offer and a single call to action.
Rewrite your headline to clearly state the outcome (not something vague or clever) Tell your prospects what’s in it for them!
Send traffic from one source (email, social, or ads) directly to that page.
If you need a little help working through the details, snag a free 15-minute call with your marketing besties to get unstuck and move your small business marketing forward!
Still not sure what to do? Take our “What’s Wrong With My Biz?” quiz and we’ll help you pinpoint exactly where your conversions are breaking down!
